John Bartleman is the President & CEO of TradeStation Group, Inc.
For more than two decades, one single number has quietly defined who actively trades in U.S. markets: $25,000. That’s the minimum equity a retail investor must maintain to freely day trade under the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA)’s Pattern Day Trading (PDT) rule.
Born in the aftermath of the dot-com bubble and the chaos that followed, the PDT rule was designed by regulators to protect inexperienced investors from taking on excessive risk. Twenty years ago, maybe it made sense: Securities trading was expensive, data was limited and professional-grade tools were scarce.
Today, markets and traders have evolved, and the rule no longer fits the times. FINRA has formally proposed updates to the PDT rule, eliminating the $25,000 equity requirement and introducing a risk-based intraday margin framework. The proposal now awaits SEC review and public comment before it takes effect (expected to happen around late 2025 or early 2026). Rather than removing safeguards, I believe that modernizing this rule redefines responsible access in a world transformed by technology, education and transparency.
Why Regulators Tapped $25,000 As The New Day Trading Regulator
In the early 2000s, retail traders began entering markets for the first time through emerging online brokers, lacking resources or knowledge to manage risk effectively. To protect increasingly anxious investors, FINRA required anyone executing more than three day trades in five business days to hold at least $25,000 in a margin account. There was a clear-cut logic: Higher capital requirements would limit excessive short-term speculation and encourage more deliberate trading behavior.
At the time, brokerage commissions were high, data feeds were expensive and education on strategies was limited. Losing $10,000 in a few trades was common. Almost immediately, the PDT rule became a defining boundary for retail traders. If you didn’t have $25,000 in your account, active or short-term trading was restricted.
Fast forward to 2025, and it’s clear that the world that led the regulators to create the PDT rule no longer exists.
Modern Markets Require Modern Rules
Today’s markets are faster, with more associated data and accessibility.
Retail participation has surged, driven by commission-free trading, fractional shares, mobile platforms and AI-powered analytics (retail investors cumulatively purchased approximately $3.4 trillion worth of equities over the first half of 2025, according to Nasdaq data). Further, securities trading education that once cost thousands is now free on brokerage websites or within trading platforms.
The risks that justified a blanket $25,000 barrier have changed. Technology has become the great equalizer. Retail investors now have access to professional-grade tools, such as real-time data, risk analytics and simulation environments.
That doesn’t mean risk has disappeared, but tools exist to allow it to be managed more effectively. Modernizing the PDT rule could deliver several key benefits:
• Expanded access and liquidity. Redesigning the threshold could invite millions of capable traders into short-term markets, deepening liquidity and efficiency.
• Innovation in retail platforms. Removing outdated constraints allows brokers and fintech firms to design new educational and risk-management tools.
• A more inclusive trading landscape. Investors with smaller balances, including younger or first-time market participants, could participate without artificial equity barriers, allowing them to learn and gain experience in their financial journeys.
Of course, there may be potential downsides. For starters, greater access can mean higher turnover among inexperienced traders and increased speculative activity. While traders have more tools at their disposal than ever, lowering barriers to entry puts them at risk for catastrophic loss if they don’t use those tools to mitigate the danger. But the upside of a more dynamic, well-educated retail base outweighs these concerns.
What Could Change, And What It Means For Traders
If approved by the SEC, FINRA’s proposed amendments would eliminate the long-standing $25,000 equity requirement for pattern day traders, replacing it with a risk-based intraday margin framework. Instead of a fixed threshold, trader exposure would be governed by existing maintenance margin standards applied throughout the trading day.
This marks a modernization that reflects today’s technology and investor diversity. The $25,000 threshold no longer distinguishes between untrained novices and informed, disciplined retail investors who actively manage risk using modern tools. Many folks use trading as a supplemental income strategy, balancing long-term investing with tactical short-term trades. Updating the PDT rule acknowledges this new reality and sends a message that regulators recognize the sophistication and responsibility of today’s retail community.
Why Now Matters
Regulation should evolve with the markets it serves. The PDT rule was crafted in a pre-smartphone, pre-AI world that assumes access equals risk, and that frequent trading inherently increases the likelihood of reckless behavior. Yet access today is paired with knowledge, data and automation that didn’t exist in 2001.
FINRA’s current proposal is more than a technical update; it’s a test case for how regulators can modernize long-standing rules to reflect a more digital, democratized marketplace. If done thoughtfully, it could become a blueprint for future regulatory reform that balances innovation with investor protection.
As a broker and technologist, I feel there’s no doubt the landscape has changed. Our clients are more informed, disciplined and better equipped. They are demanding flexibility. The focus of updating the PDT rule isn’t to eliminate protections; it’s to design smarter, adaptive ones that fit today’s reality.
Looking Ahead
The $25,000 threshold was a product of its time in an era of high commissions and limited access. Two decades later, the financial world has evolved, and so must the rules.
Technology and education have empowered retail traders to participate responsibly, and regulation should empower them in return. FINRA’s goal should be a balance that ensures markets remain safe and fair while giving investors, regardless of account size, a chance to trade, learn and grow.
The information provided here is not investment, tax or financial advice. You should consult with a licensed professional for advice concerning your specific situation.
Forbes Finance Council is an invitation-only organization for executives in successful accounting, financial planning and wealth management firms. Do I qualify?